My Lovely Green Flame Retardant Free Couch

Our wireless is down right now at home.  The internet that magically comes out of the modem still works, so it isn’t Comcast’s fault (for once!) but my cheap-o refurbished router seems to have kicked the bucket in the middle of a streaming a James Bond movie.  Sad, because we didn’t get to finish the movie, but actually not so sad at all because we’re finding the lack of wireless to be quite refreshing.

In my daily perusal of The Kitchn this morning, I spotted this little piece on a family who has decided to ditch all technology pre-1986.  This is pretty extreme, but I get it.  I don’t like how America’s tendency is to come home from school or work and immediately flip on the TV or browse the depths of the internet (keep me away from the food blogs) for hours instead of doing something, anything.

In our living room, we have a couch, but no TV. (It’s in the bedroom, not hooked up to anything, not even Netflix.) How many American families do you think have a living room that isn’t arranged around the TV? We’re probably one of the few.

I like to sit on my couch and read or even just look out the window. It’s the first couch I have ever owned and I plan to keep it for a long time, so I took great care to find an affordable one that wasn’t going to poison me.

That’s right, toxic chemicals!

A year ago, flame retardants (FRs) were all over the news. The crusade against flame retardants, chemicals put in furniture to slow fires, was led by environmental health scientist Arlene Blum.  Her research in the 1970s contributed to the ban of carcinogenic flame retardants such as the molecule brominated tris in children’s pajama fabric. The tris family of flame retardants didn’t just go away though; they continued to be used in couches, notably by Ikea until quite recently.

TDCPP, or chlorinated tris. Yum.

Since the 1970s, Blum has continued to study flame retardants. She found FRs in 85% of couches purchased in America between 1985 and 2010, mostly polybrominated diphenyl ethers (PBDEs) and halogenated organophosphates such as TDCPP, a relative of the tris from the 70s. Scientists have known for a long time that these chemicals cause cancer.  Some PBDEs were even banned in 2005 because they mimic the thyroid hormone in the human body and bioaccumulate.  These chemicals are persistent, resisting breakdown in the environment, and so are the couches that are filled with them.

The chemicals found in furniture foam are there to meet California law Technical Bulletin 117, which requires polyurethane foam to withstand igniting to an open flame.  There are debates over whether these chemicals even do anything, or if they are just used out of historical precedent.

I have a distinct memory of a conversation last fall with my advisor Terry in which he mentioned that he was working on an editorial in defense of Arlene Blum. You get a lot of personal criticism when you call out a major industry chemical as harmful.

The facts on flame retardants are scary enough to make you want to throw your couch on out on the curb right now. They’re found in your body, in your furniture, in the dust in your house, and even in arctic animals.  They’re persistent and bioaccumulative, finding a home in your body and staying there, unless they are transferred to a baby through breast milk. They’re endocrine disruptors, carcinogens, mutagens, and neurotoxins, and even the ones that have been banned are still around.

This information was enough to make public interest lawyer-mom-blogger Laura MacCleery (pretty much my blogging idol) do just that; her tris-filled Ikea couch ended up on the curb, and she wrote an amazing series of blog posts on the search for a new one.  I read them all and the hundreds of comments (whew) and thus my search for a new couch began.

Options

Until a few months ago when the TB 117 standard was modified, almost every couch in America was made to meet California standards.  This means all foam was treated with chemicals, but some natural materials do pass the flame test without the addition of FRs.  It is also theoretically possible to get a foam based couched that has not been treated with FRs (and does not comply with TB 117), but they’re harder to find.

I made this cute little flow chard to summarize the FR-free couch market.  As you will see, it gets a bit circular towards the end…FR flow

Basically, it all comes down to four option for living room seating.

1.  Couches made of all natural materials.  This is the “greenest” option, and also the most expensive. I had the pleasure of being able to sit on a couch made by Cisco Brothers in a local sustainable furniture store.  It was comfortable and beautiful, but the no FR version, called inside green, runs around $5000.  I couldn’t get an exact price quote from the sales lady or the website, but I learned all about their sustainable, naturally flame retardant materials: natural latex rubber, goose down, organic wool, etc. Cisco Brothers also offers a soy foam based couch, the merits and faults of which will be discussed below, but it is not possible to order one without FRs, and those run around $3k anyways.

I found the same general theme with other sustainable couch dealers: all natural materials that cost an arm and a leg.  If this is your thing, here are a few more sources to check out:

2.  Futon or day bed with FR free mattress instead of a real couch.  I thought about this for a while, but I just don’t love futons as couches.  FR free futons and mattresses are usually made of latex, cotton, or wool like in the fancy couches above, but buying just the mattress and futon frame is much cheaper.  However, in order to get a flame retardant free mattress you may need a note from your doctor requesting no chemicals.  I think a day bed with a lot of pillows would also look nice as a couch.

With any furniture source, make sure you explicitly ask about the FR content just to be safe, especially if the company is based in California.

3.  Make something! Upcycle something! I like the idea of making or thrifting a wooden frame and covering it in pillows and homemade cushions.

Additionally, you could also thrift a couch older than 1975, when use of flame retardants became widespread.

4.  Soy based foam that does not have flame retardants.  Soy based foam is contentious because it is actually more like 20% soy and 80% petrochemicals, and most soy crops in the US are genetically modified.  You can read more about the controversies of soy foam here.  Even though I prefer natural to petrochemical in general, I am more concerned with my own personal safety and grad student budget in this case.  Some soy is at least better than nothing, right?

Luckily, there are a few places where you can order a good old foam sofa but specifically request no flame retardants:

In the end, I ordered my couch from Ken Fonville of Eco-Select Furniture in Charleston, SC.  He has a great selection of designs available to view and order online, and he was great to work with. It was refreshing after doing so much research to talk to Ken himself on the phone and listen to him reassure me that yes, he sources FR free foams, sustainable textiles, real wood, and low/no VOC glues. He is also able to add FR free pull out beds to almost any couch. My lovely couch, sitting awkwardly in the middle of my apartment, is a loden green Presidio with a queen size bed and it cost just about $2000. I am pleased.

IMG_1080

We probably could use some art on the walls, huh? And maybe an ottoman or coffee table.

More resources on finding FR free couches and mattresses:

First, I would highly recommend reading all of Laura’s couch posts and the comments if you have the time. There you can find many little details that I have not mentioned.

The Chicago Tribune’s landmark investigative journalism series on flame retardants brought the risks of FRs to a broad audience, spurring an unusually fast policy update.  This interesting paper, written by sociologists but published in Environmental Science and Technology, analyzes how the jump from science to policy was made so quickly.  Wouldn’t it be nice if we could use this model to reform other chemical regulations?

Finally, the update of California TB 117 has removed the open flame test, which means that more options for flame retardant free couches should be on the market soon.

____

A note on the links: Many of the papers that I cite require a subscription to view more than just the abstract.  If you are interested in reading one you don’t have access to, please contact me. And also, nobody has paid or offered me anything to say any of this stuff, although my parents did kindly contribute to the couch fund on the condition that they could sleep on it when they visited. 

Advertisements

15 thoughts on “My Lovely Green Flame Retardant Free Couch

  1. Pingback: Twelve Endocrine Disruptors to Avoid | greenwake

  2. Pingback: Flame Retardant Documentary on TV TONIGHT | Green

  3. Hi Genoa,

    I am a Nutrition Counselor in CT. My program consists of seminars that focus on our ‘everyday exposures’ to toxins and their effect on our health. In my program I also provide the participants with ‘green & clean’ replacement product information. Your blog was realllly helpful as I was looking for products that wouldn’t be crazy expensive. I really appreciate the research you did & provided as well as the really good replacement suggestions. I am going to follow up with Ken regarding the clean couch. Great Job!

    Debbie
    simple 7 nutrition

  4. Hmm it looks like your site ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I had written and say,
    I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I as well am
    an aspiring blog writer but I’m still new to the whole thing.

    Do you have any tips for first-time blog writers?
    I’d definitely appreciate it.

  5. Hi! I’m thinking of ordering a couch from Eco Select and I was wondering if you could give me some feedback after nine months of use on what you like or like less about the couch you bought. Do you like the hemp fabric? Do you or your guests find the pullout bed comfortable? Is the couch generally comfortable for sitting? for lounging? Anything else you would like to share/that you wish you had known or thought of would be great. As you know, it’s not possible to try out his couches ahead of time, so your feedback is greatly appreciated. I’m hoping to order in the next few days and feeling nervous about spending so much on a couch!

    • Hi Rebecca, thanks for asking about my couch. I still love it! I am a big fan of the hemp fabric; it is much cooler in the summer than leather and soft enough to sit on with bare skin. The pullout is pretty nice for a couch bed, and Ken was able to squeeze a queen size in the couch I chose. I’ve had visitors for more than 30 nights since I got it and everybody seems to like it. I find the couch itself very comfortable for sitting and lounging. It is well stuffed (you won’t sink in) but is great with a few throw pillows. I haven’t spilled anything major on it yet so I don’t how well it would clean up, but with daily use it still looks brand new. Honestly I think my only regret overall is that I didn’t buy an ottoman, although I ended up pairing my couch with a bench-style coffee table so now I wouldn’t need it. I may go back to Ken for an overstuffed chair in the near future.

      I think my only other piece of advice is to call and talk to Ken himself if you haven’t already. He is really nice and really helpful. We talked on the phone multiple times about what I wanted before ultimately placing the order, and everything with delivery went smoothly too.

      Good look and congratulations on your flame retardant free couch! (They’re so hard to find, huh?) Please let me know if I can help with anything else!

      – G

  6. Could you tell me what the name of the style of couch and color you purchased was? I have swatches and am trying to decide color and style right now. Thanks so much!

  7. It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d most certainly donate to this brilliant blog! I guess for now i’ll settle for bookmarking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account. I look forward to brand new updates and will share this website with my Facebook group. Talk soon!

  8. Thanks for the excellent post. I’m wondering how the couch looks and sits after 2+ years. There are many FR free options now in 2016 (thanks to consumers like you), but quality seems to be on the decline. I don’t want to buy something that will be landfill in 6 or 7 years. The construction quality of this sofa appears to be much better than other, similarly priced furniture. So I’m wondering — has it held up as well as one would expect? Thanks in advance!

    • The couch is holding up beautifully! I would absolutely recommend one. The only wear and tear on it is from our cat (not the fault of the couch), and even against kitty claws it has been surprisingly resilient. All our spills so far have wiped up easily and the stuffing and cushions still feel great. Good luck!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s